Anna Hazare not voice of the people: Tharoor
How can a person 'who never stood for elections' claim to be the voice of the people, asked Shashi Tharoor.
New Delhi: Firing a salvo at Anna Hazare, former Union Minister Shashi Tharoor has said how can a person "who never stood for elections" claim to be the voice of the people.
Asserting that laws can be made only by Parliament, Tharoor, who is a first time MP from Kerala, said, "We cannot have a small group of unelected people imposing their will on Parliament because in the long term the danger will be to you the people....
"I do not believe that we can conduct democracy either from the Ramlila Ground or from television studio. Democracy must be conducted through both Houses of Parliament."
The Congress MP said there are more than 500 MPs and thousands of people's representatives in state assemblies who have gone out to seek votes of people and have to preserve the support they have got.
"If such people cannot claim to represent the people of India, but somebody else, who never stood for elections but has lot of television cameras around him and a few thousand people in a Maidan.... Will he be the voice of the people? Is that democracy?" he said addressing a gathering at Jawaharlal Nehru University here last night.
While stating that arresting Hazare was a "mistake" and that no government can disagree with the cause of the anti-corruption crusader, Tharoor stressed that the "question is the means".
"Saying that I will starve to death thereby potentially unleashing disruption violence and anarchy in the country unless you pass a bill which says exactly what I see it should say. Is that democracy? That is the question we have to ask," Tharoor said during a question-answer session with students there.
Noting that the country has a constitutional system that has kept it together for 64 years and in which people can tell their representatives about the issues, Tharoor said, "If these representatives do not pass the laws you want or pass the law you do not want, vote them out an get other representatives."
At the outset, he said that nobody can be opposed to one's right to protest or fast or the idea of the Lokpal for which Hazare stood.
"I think it was a mistake to arrest Anna Hazare," he said.
The lawmaker, however, wondered what is the guarantee that the Lokpal will "magically" be something different from other agencies, which were created to fight corruption.
He at the same time made it clear he admired Hazare, who has "lot of good qualities" and an "exemplary record of service to the country".
"I am certainly not one of those to suggest that he is anything but a man of great integrity," Tharoor said.