Get the app

DRS Is Not Completely Foolproof, Says Former Elite Panel Umpire Tarapore

Former Elite Panel umpire Shavir Tarapore talks about the use of technology in cricket and the impact it has had on umpires and umpiring.

Cricketnext Staff |March 10, 2017, 5:49 PM IST
DRS Is Not Completely Foolproof, Says Former Elite Panel Umpire Tarapore

Reporting By: Sabyasachi Roy Chowdhury

Bengaluru: In the middle of some great cricket that was played between India and Australia during the second Test match at Bengaluru, the Decision Review System (DRS) managed to grab the headlines, mostly for the wrong reasons.

The biggest controversy surrounding the DRS was about Australian captain Steve Smith waiting for signal from the dressing room on whether to review his dismissal in the second innings. The entire episode snowballed into a big row after the Indians accused Smith of 'cheating', while the Australian board put its weight behind Smith on the issue. Finally ICC decided not to charge any players and managed to strike a truce between the two teams.

Not just this, the DRS has also been under the scanner as a result of several extremely close decisions, which have been decided on umpire's call. Hence, there has been a debate about the effectiveness of technology, since technology in itself was falling back on the on-field umpire's decision on several occasions.

The decisions in case of David Warner and Virat Kohli’s dismissal in the second innings was a 50-50 call, you really could not tell whether it was right or wrong. Former International Cricket Council (ICC) Elite Panel Umpire, Shavir Tarapore spoke Exclusively to CricketNext about the Decision Review System which has been controversial since it was first put in place and also tells how much difficulty or help technology added for the umpires.

Reporter: Has DRS exposed errors in umpiring?

Tarapore: As an umpire, I don’t think many errors have been exposed as such because we have to move with the times and technology is now entering the game fast. So errors are also committed by technology itself, which we have seen. No technology is perfect in any walk of life. So trying to say that we umpires are exposed more because of the use of technology will be wrong. I think the use of technology in the game is only to make the game more fair and everyone accepts what is seen and what is given.

Reporter: How does an umpire feel when the decision is overturned?

Tarapore: I would impose the question back when you make a mistake how do you feel? As umpires, when we are officiating under technology, we are well prepared to take the ups and downs. Look at the opposite side of it, so many of times we have given a brilliant decision and technology shows that you are right so that’s all part of your mindset and your mental make-up and preparation you have done before game has started.

Reporter: How does an umpire manage when things get out of hand?

Tarapore: That is something we all are taught and that is known as match management and man management. It is a very individualistic thing and everyone has their own way of handling a situation. We are taught this when we reach the highest level. You are judged also on your performance and also on these two grades - match management and man management.

Team Rankings

Rank Team Points Rating
1 India 5211 116
2 New Zealand 3959 110
3 Australia 4320 108
4 England 5253 105
5 South Africa 3537 98
see more
Rank Team Points Rating
1 England 6967 124
2 India 7939 118
3 New Zealand 5347 116
4 South Africa 5602 112
5 Australia 5915 110
see more
Rank Team Points Rating
1 Pakistan 8926 270
2 Australia 7815 269
3 England 6407 267
4 India 12141 264
5 South Africa 6220 259
see more