GET Stock QuotesNews18 APP
News18 English
Powered by cricketnext logo
»
1-min read

Can NCLT Adjudicate on Removal of Board Chairman, Asks Tata Lawyer

"If you have friends like Cyrus (Mistry), one needs no enemies," Tata group counsel Abhishek Manu Singhvi told the National Company Law Tribunal.

PTI

Updated:February 3, 2018, 9:36 AM IST
facebookTwittergoogleskypewhatsapp
Can NCLT Adjudicate on Removal of Board Chairman, Asks Tata Lawyer
File image. (Reuters)
Mumbai: Tata Sons on Friday launched a frontal attack on its ousted former chairman Cyrus Mistry, saying after his removal from the group he behaved like a "Trojan Horse", and also questioned whether the National Company Law Tribunal can adjudicate upon a board's decision to remove the chairman.

"If you have friends like Cyrus (Mistry), one needs no enemies," Tata group counsel Abhishek Manu Singhvi told the NCLT.

After his removal, Mistry was behaving like a "Trojan Horse", he added.

Mistry's behaviour after his removal was malafide, reckless and unprecedented as he failed in his fiduciary responsibilities as a director on the board of Tata Sons, Singhvi said.

As an example, he cited the detailed reply Mistry sent to the Income Tax department's notice in December 2016 even when he had no compulsion to send it.

"But he did so only with malafide intention to cause trouble for a company which he continued to serve as a director," he said.

There were heated moments during the argument today as Singhvi claimed that Mistry's lawyer Somashekar Sunderashan was trying to bring in points which were never raised in the original pleadings.

Sunderashan took exception and sought permission to correlate his latest submission with the original pleadings.

The tribunal, however, said whether arguments should be confined to the points raised in pleadings was a matter of ethics.

Mistry continued to be a director on the board of Tata Sons for five months after his removal as the chairman on October 24, 2016.

The shareholders voted him out of the board on February 6, 2017.

Wondering whether the NCLT can adjudicate on Mistry's removal by the board which had lost confidence in him, Singhvi argued in fact, Mistry has not yet challenged his removal but is only questioning the process of removal.

Mistry and the Tatas are locked in a bitter legal battle since his ouster from the Tata group.

Two Mistry family firms — Cyrus Investments and Sterling Investments — have moved the NCLT alleging oppression of minority shareholders and mismanagement at the Tata group.

Also Watch

| Edited by: Puja Menon
Read full article
Most Active
Company Price Change %Gain
Reliance 920.80 +4.95 +0.54
Vedanta 251.80 +1.20 +0.48
TCS 3,585.80 -17.90 -0.50
United Spirits 3,250.30 +131.15 +4.20
SBI 266.95 -1.55 -0.58
Company Price Change %Gain
HDFC 1,820.00 +13.95 +0.77
Just Dial 507.40 +42.55 +9.15
Avenue Supermar 1,497.45 +93.25 +6.64
PC Jeweller 192.45 +4.40 +2.34
United Spirits 3,251.00 +128.95 +4.13
Top Gainers
Company Price Change %Gain
Indiabulls Hsg 1,172.10 +60.30 +5.42
Hindalco 245.50 +11.40 +4.87
IOC 163.45 +7.55 +4.84
ONGC 175.45 +7.75 +4.62
HPCL 295.20 +11.95 +4.22
Company Price Change %Gain
ONGC 175.35 +7.70 +4.59
Tata Steel 567.20 +18.80 +3.43
Yes Bank 339.45 +8.95 +2.71
Adani Ports 379.90 +8.70 +2.34
IndusInd Bank 1,914.75 +43.55 +2.33
Top Losers
Company Price Change %Gain
Coal India 275.60 -4.50 -1.61
Tech Mahindra 702.75 -8.60 -1.21
Bharti Infratel 314.85 -3.50 -1.10
ITC 272.30 -2.55 -0.93
ICICI Bank 295.65 -2.05 -0.69
Company Price Change %Gain
Coal India 276.05 -3.80 -1.36
ITC 271.95 -2.85 -1.04
SBI 267.00 -1.50 -0.56
TCS 3,589.45 -15.35 -0.43
ICICI Bank 296.50 -0.75 -0.25