The Bombay High Court on Wednesday permitted Delhi University’s associate professor Hany Babu, an accused in the Elgar Parishad-Maoist links case, to be shifted to the private Breach Candy Hospital here for medical treatment. Hany Babu moved the HC on Wednesday morning seeking medical aid for an eye infection which he developed after contracting COVID-19.
The HC said Babu should be shifted to the Breach Candy Hospital on Thursday under police protection, and charges for his treatment there and medicines prescribed will be borne by him and his family. Hany Babu tested positive for coronavirus earlier this month and is currently undergoing treatment at the state-run G T Hospital in Mumbai.
Last week, authorities of the Taloja prison in neighbouring Navi Mumbai brought him to the J J Hospital here, from where he was shifted to the G T Hospital. His wife Jenny Rowena moved the HC on Wednesday morning, seeking interim bail and medical aid for him.
Her counsel, senior advocate Yug Chaudhry, approached a vacation bench of Justices S J Kathawalla and S P Tavade, seeking an urgent hearing on the ground that besides testing positive for coronavirus, Babu had also developed a severe eye infection and ran the risk of losing vision in his left eye. Chaudhry said Babu must be checked to rule out the possibility of black fungus.
Mucormycosis, or black fungus, is a rare but serious infection which has been found in several COVID-19 patients. The bench, accordingly, summoned the G T Hospital’s Dean Dr B G Chikhalkar, who appeared with other doctors via video-conferencing and told the bench that Babu was being provided adequate treatment.
The court then asked for a video call to be arranged between the bench and Hany Babu. When Babu came on the line, he told the HC that he was satisfied with the treatment at the G T Hospital.
“My eye is a little better now. I am satisfied," he said. The hospital authorities told the HC that they were not equipped to carry out an MRI angio test that had been recommended for Babu’s brain by the J J Hospital.
Advocate Chaudhry told the HC that Babu also needed several other specialised tests to be conducted and sought interim bail. “If the state can’t take care of me, let me take care of myself and my life," Chaudhry argued.
The HC said while it won’t grant bail to Babu, it could allow him to be shifted to a hospital of his choice. The NIA’s counsel, Additional Solicitor General Anil Singh, opposed it and said the city-based J J Hospital, KEM Hospital, Nair Hospital were all equipped to treat Babu.
“Otherwise, this will become a precedent and all prisoners will want to be shifted to private hospitals," Singh said. The HC, however, refused to accept the submission.
“Let the family get psychological satisfaction at least that he is being treated at a hospital of their choice, especially if they are footing the bill," the court said. The HC said there is nothing wrong in making this a precedent, especially in the current situation.
“That’s why we are asking him to pay the bill. We haven’t taken the Nanavati precedent and asked state to pay the bill," the HC said. It was referring to a previous HC order that had directed the private Nanavati Hospital here to bear the treatment cost of activist Varavara Rao, who is also an accused in the Elgar Parishad-Maoist links case.
The HC directed the Breach Candy Hospital to submit Babu’s medical report in court by June 9, the next date of hearing, or whenever Babu is discharged from the hospital. As per his family and lawyer, Babu developed an acute eye infection on May 3, and is yet to receive appropriate medical care.
Last week, Babu’s wife Jenny Rowena, said in a press conference that his family was struggling to get information from prison authorities and the NIA, which is conducting a probe into the case, on his health condition. Babu was arrested by the National Investigation Agency (NIA) in July 2020.
The Elgar Parishad case relates to alleged inflammatory speeches made at a conclave held in Pune on December 31, 2017, which police claimed triggered violence the next day near the Koregaon-Bhima war memorial in the district. The Pune police claimed the conclave was backed by Maoists.
The case was later taken over by the NIA. Several other activists, including Sudha Bharadwaj and Varavara Rao, had been arrested in the case.